Back in Indonesia, people around me generally has the idea that almost every single South Korean celebrity has gone under the knife, especially the female ones. I remember when I was watching Girls' Generation music video "Dancing Queen" several years ago on my living room television, my mother came over and watched the video together with me. Several seconds into the video, she commented, "They are really skinny and pretty, do they even eat?" and then she continues again, "How can all of them be so pretty, how many times did they fix their faces?"
I thought it would end there. But the next day, when I was watching a Korean variety show Strong Heart, she looked at one of the guests and commented, "Oh, this one is not as pretty as the ones you showed me yesterday. But she had some surgeries too, right?" And not only my mom, most of my friends also had similar comments.
So, are all k-pop idols "artificial"? I doubt so. I believe some of them are what people like to call "Natural beauties", and I also think that even the ones who had gone under the knife did not reconstruct their whole face, just some particular part, such as nose or jaw. But still, since plastic surgery is not very common in most countries and even is considered taboo by some people, I can understand why my mom or other people think that all k-pop idols had done it.
Can we really blame them though? In a society where even normal people care so much about their looks, a celebrity would be forced to look as good as possible. Lee Jung-bok, 17, a contestant of K-pop Star from Los Angeles said that talent still trumps looks, but looks are major selling point in the industry. Lee added, "When I was in K-pop Star, they wanted me to be a typical looking star... You can't be who you are. It's like being a puppet". Lee also said that her friends get plastic surgery to look prettier, "They want to look like Girls' Generation and f(x)... They want to be pretty like them".
Around a decade ago, the majority of Koreans receiving plastic surgeries are females in their 20s and 30s. But then the trend shifted to younger generation, as more teenagers went under the knife. In 2011, an e-Seoul survey reported by JoongAng Daily found that 41.4 percent of teens were "willing to have plastic surgery for beauty". While it is difficult to prove that this phenomenon is caused by K-pop explosion, everyone knows that k-pop artists are not only recognized for their music, but also their physical appearance. The fact that this trend started right after the boom of K-pop strengthen the belief that K-pop was the cause of this phenomenon. Coincidence? Maybe, maybe not.

1-0 for Looks
But hey, there are many cases where the statement is correct also. I picked two examples, one is the world star Psy, and the other one is the K-pop Star 2 winners Akdong Musician. Everyone knows Psy, right? Everyone knows Gangnam Style. Everyone also knows that Psy's success was not driven by his outer appearance. His looks were not objectively stunning (hey, some people like his looks, mind you), but his charisma and ability in composing catchy tunes brought him up there.
1-1. For both talent and looks. Tie.
As for Akdong Musician, while they are still not well known by people outside of Korea, they have a huge popularity here. Most people think they don't look as good as most celebrity do, but whenever they release a song, it becomes a hit. Of course the fact that they got recognition through K-pop Star must not be forgotten, but they became the winner because of their talent too, so...
2-1 for Talent
Well, there are millions of examples out there, whether in Korea or out of Korea. Whether you like talent better or looks better, whether you like natural beauty or "enhanced" beauty, that's up to your choice, folks. The important thing is...
Be a nice person.
And also....
Bye everyone~